Are BMW X5 Reliable? (Read This First)

The BMW X5 is a comfortable and luxurious SUV that’s quick and easy to drive.

However, before you go and buy one, it’s important to consider the X5s reliability.

In this article, we’ll take a closer look at how reliable the X5 is, which year is the most reliable, and how its reliability compares to similar SUVs.

Are BMW X5 Reliable? (Read This First)

Quick Answer: Are BMW X5 Reliable?

The BMW X5 has pretty average reliability, with more recent years scoring much better than other years.

Both Consumer Reports and JD Power regularly give the X5 low to average scores for reliability. The X5 also produces a high number of recalls.

RepairPal marks the BMW X5 a sorry 2 out of 5 for reliability and ranks it 13th out of 19 full-size luxury SUVs. They also report high annual maintenance costs for the X5, averaging $1,166 per year compared to only $1,127 for all luxury full-size SUVs.

That said, it’s important to remember that most luxury SUVs get similar reliability ratings to the X5. Luxury cars are generally not built with reliability as their number one priority, because most luxury car buyers are upgrading after a few years of ownership.

If reliability is your number one concern, you’d be better off buying a Japanese SUV like the Rav4 that is built specifically for reliability.

You might also like: How Long Do BMW X5 Last? (Explained)

What Year BMW X5 Is The Most Reliable?

The 2018 BMW X5 is the most reliable X5 Year in the last decade. Both Consumer Reports (4/5) and JD power (84/100) awarded the 2018 X5 solid marks for reliability, while it enjoyed a relatively low number of recalls compared to other years.

BMW X5 Reliability By Year

Let’s take a look at the reliability of the BMW over the last 5 years. We’ll look at the reliability ratings from JD Power and COnsumer reports, as well as the number of recalls from the NHSTA.

JD Power Reliability RatingConsumer Reports Reliability RatingNumber of Recalls
2021 BMW X577/100 (Average)4/511
2020 BMW X581/100 (Great)4/58
2019 BMW X566/100 (fair)3/510
2018 BMW X584/100 (Great)4/54
2017 BMW X580/100 (Average)3/55
2016 BMW X580/100 (Average)3/54
2015 BMW X581/100 (Great)3/56
2014 BMW X579/100 (Average)2/56
2013 BMW X582/100 (Great)2/57
2012 BMW X577/100 (Average)2/510

Is The 2019 BMW X5 Reliable?

The 2019 BMW X5 got a reliability rating of 66/100 from JD Power which is lower than any BMW X5 in the last 10 years. It also had a fairly high number of recalls (10).

NHTSA reported 10 safety recalls of the 2019 BMW X5:

  1. Airbags not properly deploying
  2. ABS brake assistance not working
  3. rearview camera blindspots
  4. loose steering bearing plate
  5. loose wheel bolts
  6. improperly tightened seat belt bolts
  7. fuel leak risk
  8. missing restraint usage guidelines
  9. BDC shortcircuit could cause other components to overheat

Is The 2018 BMW X5 Reliable?

JD Power gave the 2018 BMW X5 a reliability rating of 84/100, which they consider “great”. The 2018 BMW X5 got the highest reliability rating of any BMW X5 model in the last 10 years. It also had a relatively low number of recalls (4) as compared to other X5 years.

NHTSA reported 4 safety recalls of the 2018 BMW X5:

  1. The high-pressure fuel pump can fail.
  2. There is a risk of shock or fire from the power cable.
  3. The lower control arm can break.
  4. The wishbone suspension bolts are incorrectly torqued.

Is The 2017 BMW X5 Reliable?

The 2017 BMW X5 got an 80/100 reliability rating from JD Power, which they consider “average”. It also had an average number of recalls (5) as compared to other BMW X5 models of the last 10 years.

The NHTSA reported 5 safety recalls of the 2017 BMW X5:

  1. A coolant leak inside the EGR module can cause a fire.
  2. The high-pressure fuel pump can fail.
  3. A coolant leak within the EGR can cause a fire.
  4. A tire information label is incorrect.
  5. The passenger frontal air bag inflator can rupture. 

Is The 2016 BMW X5 Reliable?

JD Power gave the 2016 BMW X5 an 80/100 reliability rating, which they consider “average”. It also had a fairly low number of recalls (4) as compared to other X5 models of the last decade.

NHTSA reported 4 safety recalls of the 2016 BMW X5:

  1. A coolant leak inside the EGR module can cause a fire.
  2. The high-pressure fuel pump can fail.
  3. A coolant leak within the EGR can cause a fire.
  4. A loose ground cable can cause gears to shift to neutral.

Is The 2015 BMW X5 Reliable?

JD Powers gave the 2015 BMW X5 a reliability rating of 81/100, which they consider “great”. It also had an average number of recalls (6) when compared to other BMW X5 models of the last 10 years.

NHTSA reported 6 safety recalls of the 2015 BMW X5:

  1. A coolant leak inside the EGR module can cause a fire.
  2. The high-pressure fuel pump can fail.
  3. A coolant leak within the EGR can cause a fire.
  4. The driver’s airbag inflator is incorrectly welded.
  5. Improper inflation of the head protection system’s airbag.
  6. An issue with the left rear seat frame steel plate.

You might also like: How Long Do BMW’s Last? (Explained)

Is The 2014 BMW X5 Reliable?

The 2014 BMW X5 got a 79/100 reliability rating from JD Power, which they consider “average”. It also had a slightly higher than average number of recalls (6) as compared to other BMW X5 models of the last 10 years.

NHTSA reported 6 safety recalls of the 2014 BMW X5:

  1. A coolant leak inside the EGR module can cause a fire.
  2. The high-pressure fuel pump can fail.
  3. A coolant leak within the EGR can cause a fire.
  4. The driver’s airbag inflator is incorrectly welded.
  5. Improper inflation of the head protection system’s airbag.
  6. The child safety locks can disengage. 

Is The 2013 BMW X5 Reliable?

The 2013 BMW X5 got a reliability rating of 82/100, which they consider “great”. It also had a higher than average number of recalls (7) as compared to other BMW X5 models of the last ten years.

NHTSA reported 7 safety recalls of the 2013 BMW X5:

  1. The driver’s airbag inflator can explode.
  2. The passenger frontal air bag inflator can explode (2 safety recalls).
  3. The engine belt idler pulley bolt can loosen or break.
  4. The front driveshaft universal ball joint can fail.
  5. The driver’s airbag inflator can rupture.
  6. A problem with the steering gear.

Is The 2012 BMW X5 Reliable?

The 2012 BMW X5 received a reliability rating of 77/100 from JD Power, which they consider “average”. It had a high number of recalls (10) as compared to other BMW X5 models of the last 10 years.

NHTSA reports 10 safety recalls of the 2012 BMW X5:

  1. The passenger airbag inflators can explode (2 safety recalls).
  2. The driver’s airbag inflators can explode.
  3. The passenger frontal air bag inflator can explode.
  4. The engine belt idler pulley bolt can loosen or break.
  5. The electric auxiliary water pump can fail.
  6. The front driveshaft universal joint can fail.
  7. The passenger frontal air bag inflator can rupture.
  8. A problem with the steering gear.
  9. An issue with the transmission parking lock.

Is The 2011 BMW X5 Reliable?

JD Power gave the 2011 BMW X5 a reliability rating of 78/100, which they consider “average”. It had a much higher number of recalls (14) than any BMW X5 model in the last 10 years.

NHTSA reported 14 safety recalls of the 2011 BMW X5:

  1. The passenger frontal air bag inflator can explode (2 safety recalls). 
  2. The driver’s airbag inflators can explode.
  3. The passenger frontal air bag inflator can explode.
  4. The engine belt idler pulley bolt can loosen or break.
  5. The electric auxiliary water pump can fail (2 safety recalls).
  6. The PVC heater can short circuit.
  7. The front driveshaft universal joint can fail (2 safety recalls).
  8. Loose wiring in the fuel pump can cause a stall or a fuel leak.
  9. The passenger frontal air bag inflator can rupture.
  10. An issue with the engine belt tensioner.
  11. An incorrect tire pressure label.

Is The 2010 BMW X5 Reliable?

The 2010 BMW X5 got a reliability rating of 78/100 from JD Power, which they consider “average”. It also had a huge number of recalls (20) as compared to other BMW X5 models of the last 10 years. 

NHTSA reported 20 safety recalls of the 2010 BMW X5:

  1. The passenger frontal air bag inflator can explode (2 safety recalls).
  2. The driver’s airbag inflators can explode.
  3. The passenger frontal air bag inflator can explode.
  4. The engine belt idler pulley bolt can loosen or break (2 safety recalls).
  5. The electric auxiliary water pump can fail.
  6. The PVC heater can short circuit.
  7. Loose wiring in the fuel pump can cause a stall or a fuel leak.
  8. The passenger frontal air bag inflator can rupture.
  9. The driver’s airbag inflator can rupture.
  10. The camshaft housing bolts can loosen and cause a stall.
  11. The fuel filter heater can cause a fire.
  12. A leak in the brake vacuum pump can cause a loss of power assist.
  13. An issue with the battery cable insulated bulkhead connector.
  14. A problem with the electric auxiliary water pump.
  15. An issue with the brake vacuum pump.
  16. A problem with the fuel level sensor.
  17. An issue with side marker lamps.
  18. A problem with the bonding of the windshield. 

Is The 2009 BMW X5 Reliable?

JD Power gave the 2009 BMW X5 a reliability rating of 72/100, which they consider “average”. It also had a much higher than average number of recalls (18) as compared to BMW X5 models of the last 10 years. 

NHTSA reported 18 safety recalls of the 2009 BMW X5:

  1. The passenger airbag inflators can explode. 
  2. The driver’s airbag inflators can explode.
  3. The passenger frontal air bag inflator can explode (2 safety recalls).
  4. The engine belt idler pulley bolt can loosen or break (2 safety recalls).
  5. The PVC heater can short circuit.
  6. The passenger frontal air bag inflator can rupture (2 safety recalls).
  7. Loose fuel pump wiring can cause a fuel leak or a stall.
  8. The driver’s airbag inflator can rupture.
  9. The fuel filter heater can cause a fire (2 safety recalls).
  10. A leak in the brake vacuum pump can cause a loss of power assist.
  11. An issue with engine cool fan assembly and service parts.
  12. An issue with the battery cable insulated bulkhead connector.
  13. An issue with the brake vacuum pump.
  14. A problem with the rear brake discs. 

Is The 2008 BMW X5 Reliable?

The 2008 BMW X5 received a reliability rating of 73/100 from JD Power, which they consider “average”. It also had a high number of recalls (15) as compared to BMW X5 models of the last 10 years. 

NHTSA reported 15 safety recalls of the 2008 BMW X5:

  1. The passenger airbag inflators can explode. 
  2. The driver’s airbag inflators can explode.
  3. The passenger frontal air bag inflator can explode (2 safety recalls).
  4. The PVC heater can short circuit.
  5. The passenger frontal air bag inflator can rupture (2 safety recalls).
  6. Loose fuel pump wiring can cause a fuel leak or a stall.
  7. The driver’s airbag inflator can rupture.
  8. A leak in the brake vacuum pump can cause a loss of power assist.
  9. An issue with engine cool fan assembly and service parts.
  10. An issue with the battery cable insulated bulkhead connector.
  11. A malfunction in the fuel pump.
  12. An issue with the brake vacuum pump.
  13. A problem with the rear axle stabilizer.

Is The 2007 BMW X5 Reliable?

JD Power gave the 2007 BMW X5 a reliability rating of 71/100, which they consider “average”. It also had a higher than average number of recalls (15) as compared to other BMW X5 models of the last 10 years. 

NHTSA reported 15 safety recalls of the 2007 BMW X5:

  1. The passenger airbag inflators can explode.
  2. The passenger frontal air bag inflator can explode (2 safety recalls).
  3. The driver’s airbag inflators can explode.
  4. The PVC heater can short circuit.
  5. The passenger frontal air bag inflator can rupture (2 safety recalls).
  6. Loose fuel pump wiring can cause a fuel leak or a stall.
  7. The driver’s airbag inflator can rupture.
  8. A leak in the brake vacuum pump can cause a loss of power assist.
  9. An issue with engine cool fan assembly and service parts.
  10. An issue with the battery cable insulated bulkhead connector.
  11. An issue with the brake vacuum pump.
  12. An issue with the engine electronics.
  13. A problem with the brake fluid reservoir cap.

Is The 2006 BMW X5 Reliable?

JD Power rated the 2006 BMW X5 82/100 in terms of reliability, which they consider “great”. It had an average number of recalls (8) as compared to BMW X5 models of the last 10 years. 

NHTSA reports 8 safety recalls of the 2006 BMW X5:

  1. A defect in the front seat occupation mat.
  2. An issue with engine cool fan assembly and service parts.
  3. An issue with the battery cable insulated bulkhead connector.
  4. An issue with the brake vacuum pump.
  5. An issue with the front passenger occupation mat.
  6. A problem with the rear shock absorbers. 
  7. An issue with the front axle control arm and the tension strut nuts.
  8. A problem with the park pawl guide plate.

Is The 2005 BMW X5 Reliable?

The 2005 BMW X5 had a higher than average number of recalls (7) as compared to the BMW X5 models of the last 10 years.

NHTSA reported 7 safety recalls of the 2005 BMW X5:

  1. A problem with the engine cooling fan or service parts.
  2. An issue with the battery cable insulated bulkhead connector.
  3. An issue with the brake vacuum pump.
  4. A problem with the front passenger seat occupation mat.
  5. An issue with aftermarket bike carriers.
  6. A problem with the park pawl guide plate.
  7. A problem with the brake line support bracket

You might also like: BMW Brake Fluid (13 Questions Answered)

How Does BMW X5 Reliability Compare To Similar SUVs?

While the BMW X5 might not have the best reliability when compared to some reliability-first brands like Toyota or Honda, they still hold their own when compared to other luxury SUVs.

BMW X5 vs Audi Q5 Reliability

The BMW X5 and the Audi Q5 have similar overall reliability. Although the BMW X5 has received slightly higher reliability ratings than the Audi Q5 over the last 4 years.

However, the BMW X5 has had a larger number of recalls than the Audi Q5 over the same time period.

JD Power ReliabilityNumber of Recalls
2020 BMW X581/100 (Great)8
2020 Audi Q565/100 (Fair)3
2019 BMW X566/100 (Fair)0
2019 Audi Q578/100 (Average)4
2018 BMW X584/100 (Great)4
2018 Audi Q576/100 (Average)5
2017 BMW X580/100 (Average)5
2017 Audi Q582/100 (Great)5

BMW X5 vs Mercedes GLE Reliability

The Mercedes GLE is a more reliable car than the BMW X5. The Mercedes GLE has received higher reliability ratings from JD Power in the last 4 years than the BMW X5.

However, the Mercedes GLE has had a much higher number of recalls than the BMW X5 in the same time period.  

JD Power ReliabilityNumber of Recalls
2020 BMW X581/100 (Great)8
2020 Mercedes GLE69/100 (Fair)26
2019 BMW X566/100 (Fair)0
2019 Mercedes GLE83/100 (Great)0
2018 BMW X584/100 (Great)4
2018 Mercedes GLE84/100 (Great)6
2017 BMW X580/100 (Average)5
2017 Mercedes GLE84/100 (Great)10

BMW X5 vs Audi Q7 Reliability

The BMW X5 and the Audi Q7 are similar in terms of reliability. Although the BMW X5 has received higher reliability ratings, on average, from JD Power in the last 4 years than the Audi Q7.

Both cars have had a similar number of recalls over the last 4 years.

JD Power ReliabilityNumber of Recalls
2020 BMW X581/100 (Great)8
2020 Audi Q7Not Rated2
2019 BMW X566/100 (Fair)0
2019 Audi Q775/100 (Average)4
2018 BMW X584/100 (Great)4
2018 Audi Q776/100 (Average)3
2017 BMW X580/100 (Average)5
2017 Audi Q772/100 (Average)7

BMW X5 vs Range Rover Sport

The BMW X5 and the Range Rover Sport are similar in terms of reliability.

Both cars have received similar reliability ratings from JD Powers, although the BMW X5 has received slightly higher reliability ratings than the Range Rover Sport.

However, the BMW X5 has had a higher number of recalls than the Range Rover Sport in the last 4 years. 

JD Power ReliabilityNumber of Recalls
2020 BMW X581/100 (Great)8
2020 Range Rover Sport65/100 (Fair)3
2019 BMW X566/100 (Fair)10
2019 Range Rover Sport72/100 (Average)2
2018 BMW X584/100 (Great)4
2018 Range Rover SportNot Rated3
2017 BMW X580/100 (Average)5
2017 Range Rover SportNot Rated5

BMW X5 vs Volvo XC90 Reliability

The BMW X5 is a more reliable car than the Volvo XC90. Over the last 4 years, JD Power has given higher reliability ratings to the BMW X5 than the Volvo XC90.

However, both cars have had roughly the same number of recalls over the same time period. 

JD Power ReliabilityNumber of Recalls
2020 BMW X581/100 (Great)8
2020 Volvo XC9071/100 (Average)4
2019 BMW X566/100 (Fair)10
2019 Volvo XC9074/100 (Average)4
2018 BMW X584/100 (Great)4
2018 Volvo XC9074/100 (Average)2
2017 BMW X580/100 (Average)5
2017 Volvo XC9061/100 (Fair)6

BMW X5 vs X3 Reliability

The BMW X5 and the BMW X3 are very similar when it comes to reliability.

Both cars have received more or less similar reliability ratings from JD Power over the last 4 years.

However, the BMW X3 has had a significantly larger number of recalls over the same time period than the BMW X5.

JD Power ReliabilityNumber of Recalls
2020 BMW X581/100 (Great)8
2020 BMW X379/100 (Average)12
2019 BMW X566/100 (Fair)10
2019 BMW X379/100 (Average)8
2018 BMW X584/100 (Great)4
2018 BMW X378/100 (Average)9
2017 BMW X580/100 (Average)5
2017 BMW X386/100 (Great)5

BMW X5 vs MDX Reliability

The BMW X5 is a more reliable car than the Acura MDX.

JD Power has given the BMW X5 higher reliability ratings over the last 4 years than the Acura MDX. However, the BMW X5 has had a slightly higher number of recalls over the same time period.

JD Power ReliabilityNumber of Recalls
2020 BMW X581/100 (Great)8
2020 Acura MDX80/100 (Average)1
2019 BMW X566/100 (Fair)10
2019 Acura MDX78/100 (Average)4
2018 BMW X584/100 (Great)4
2018 Acura MDX81/100 (Great)5
2017 BMW X580/100 (Average)5
2017 Acura MDX77/100 (Average)3

BMW X5 vs Mercedes ML Reliability

The Mercedes ML and BMW X5 are pretty similar when it comes to reliability.

While JD Power has given the Mercedes ML slightly higher reliability ratings on average over the last 4 years than the BMW X5, the Mercedes ML has had a larger number of recalls.

JD Power ReliabilityNumber of Recalls
2020 BMW X581/100 (Great)8
2020 Mercedes ML69/100 (Fair)26
2019 BMW X566/100 (Fair)10
2019 Mercedes ML83/100 (Great)0
2018 BMW X584/100 (Great)4
2018 Mercedes ML84/100 (Great)6
2017 BMW X580/100 (Average)5
2017 Mercedes ML84/100 (Great)10

BMW X5 vs Lexus RX 350 Reliability

The Lexus RX 350 is usually considered a more reliable car than the BMW X5. JD Power has given the Lexus RX 350 higher reliability ratings than the BMW X5 every year over the last 4 years. The Lexus RX 350 has also had a much smaller number of recalls than the BMW X5.

JD Power ReliabilityNumber of Recalls
84/100 (Great)81/100 (Great)8
2020 Lexus RX 35084/100 (Great)1
2019 BMW X566/100 (Fair)10
2019 Lexus RX 35085/100 (Great)3
2018 BMW X584/100 (Great)4
2018 Lexus RX 35086/100 (Great)1
2017 BMW X580/100 (Average)5
2017 Lexus RX 35083/100 (Great)3

Article Sources: