Discount Tire Vs Costco (Which Is Better?)

Discount tire and Costco are two places that can save you a considerable amount of money when it comes time to buy new tires.

But which is better to use?

Discount Tire vs Costco:

Discount Tire carries more brands and more models of tires. They also have a low price guarantee that ensures they will get you the best price possible. Costco regularly has out-of-stock tires, but they offer a slightly better warranty than Discount Tires.

Read on to find out how each retailer stacks up against one another, so you can better determine which is the right choice for your needs.

discount tire vs costco (which is better?)

Discount Tire Pros:

  • Free Tire Rotation & balancing
  • More tires stocked than Costco
  • Financing options
  • Cheaper tires than Costco

Discount Tire Cons:

  • The only financing option is with a credit card
  • Mixed customer reviews
  • You have to pay for extra warranty

Costco Tire Pros:

  • Low pricing
  • Excellent 5-year warranty

Costco Tire Cons:

  • Don’t stock many tires
  • Constantly out of stock
  • Free rotation and balancing service
  • Not as cheap as Discount Tire
  • No advance appointments

Which Has Cheaper Tires?

Discount Tire offers more affordable tires compared to Costco.

And thanks to their Low Price Guarantee, Discount Tire will do whatever it can to ensure that you get the lowest price possible on the tires they sell.

Let’s take a look at how the same tires compare at Discount and Costco

Discount TirePricesCostco Prices
Goodyear Assurance WeatherReady$177Bridgestone Turanza EL400-02$198.99
Continental Control Contact Sport SRS$128Bridgestone Ecopia EP422 Plus$177.99
Goodyear Eagle Exhilarate$147Michelin Primacy MXM4$168.99
Michelin Pilot Sport A/S 3 Plus$159Michelin Pilot Sport Cup 2 (240)$262.99
Barum Bravurius 5HM$66Bridgestone BLIZZAK WS90$176.99

As you can see from the table above, Discount Tire is considerably cheaper than Costco.

Discount Tire also provides a low match guarantee, so if you find the tires cheaper somewhere else, they will match that price.

If you want to take advantage of Discount Tire’s Low Price Guarantee, you will need to bring in a valid ad that features the price in question. 

You might also like: OEM Tires (Everything You Need To Know)

Which Has The Better Tire Warranty?

Costco has a better tire warranty.

In addition to the standard tire manufacturer warranty, Costco provides a free 5 year “Road Hazard Protection” warranty for all of its tires.

Discount also offers a standard manufacturer’s warranty, but you need to pay extra for their 3-year warranty.

Many of the tires stocked at Discount and Costco come with a standard distance warranty from the manufacturer.

These typically provide a warranty for between 50k and 80k miles depending on the brand.

If you drive 15k miles per year, this would cover you for around 3-5 years.

Discount Tire Warranty

As well as the standard distance warranty provided by the manufacturers, Discount Tire offers its own “Discount Tire Certificate,” which works like a three-year warranty.

If your tires fail during this time period, you can get a full refund or replacement.

However, keep in mind that you’ll pay extra per tire for this guarantee.

Prices depend on the brand and model you’re buying.

This fee can range anywhere from $10 to $100 a tire.

Not every tire that Discount Tire stocks come with a standard manufacturer’s warranty.

Tires that do, all have varying lengths of the standard warranty.

Costco Tire Warranty

Costco’s Road Hazard Protection guarantee, which protects your tires against tire failure or treadwear damage for five years.

If failure or damage occurs within that timeframe, Costco will repair or replace the tire.

Costco is good about this and will honor their Road Hazard Warranty under most circumstances.

If you choose to have your tire replaced, Costco does this in the form of a credit that goes toward your purchase and is determined by remaining tread analysis.

Which Stocks More Tires?

Discount Tire has way more tire options than Costco.

If you like variety and appreciate having different options to choose from, Discount Tire is going to be your best bet.

Let’s take a look at the tires that Costco and Discount Tires stock:

Discount TireCostco
ArislinBFGoodrich
ArizonianBridgestone
AtturoMichelin
Barum
BFGoodrich
Braven
Bridgestone
Carlisle
Coker Tire
Continental
Cooper Tires
Corsa
Dunlop
EZGO
Falken Tires
Fierce
Firestone
GBC Motorsports
General Tire
Gladiator
GMZ
Goodyear
GTRadial
Hankook
Hartland
Interco Tire Corporation
Kanati
Kumho Tire
Laufenn
Maxxis Tires
Michelin
Mickey Thompson
MileStar Tires
Mohave
Journey
Nankang
Nexen Tire
Nitto
Nokian Tyres
OHTSU Tires
PathFinder
Phantom
Pirelli
Pitbull
Pro Comp
Rage Tires & Wheels
Road Hugger
Sentury Tire
Taskmaster
Tensor Tire
Trailfinder
Uniroyal
Vision Wheel
Vogue Tyres
West Lake Tires
Yokohama

It’s also worth noting that Costco is consistently out of stock on many of its tires.

This isn’t the case with Discount Tire. They routinely stock their inventory, thus ensuring that you can get most tires when needed.

Trade-in Options

Discount Tire won’t buy your used tires from you, but you might be able to trade them in when you buy new tires.

This would serve as a credit that goes toward the total purchase price of your new tires.

Exactly how much of a credit you will receive is unknown, as it depends on several factors, such as your tires’ age, brand, model, tread, and so on.

What’s more, most credits are usually pretty small, so don’t go in expecting to get your brand-new tires half off or anything.

The best thing you can do is stop by your local Discount Tire store so they can see first-hand what kind of condition your tires are in.

They’re going to need to be inspected anyway.

But if you’re trying to determine what kind of credit you’ll receive so you can better budget your new tires, call ahead of time to schedule an appointment for them to look at your existing tires.

Trade-ins don’t appear to be an option through Costco. This is likely because they don’t sell used tires, whereas Discount Tire does.

What’s more, Costco’s system is set up in a way that prevents them from accepting any tires with a DOT date older than two years.

You might also like: How Old Should New Tires Be? (Explained)

Customer Service

It’s fair to say that both Costco and Discount Tires get mixed reviews when it comes to customer service and feedback.

Coscto Tire Centre currently gets a rating of 1.5/5 on Cunsumer Affairs

The most helpful review mentions the fact that the installation team at Costco broke a lug nut and refuse to fix or replace it. Yikes!

Discount Tires scored slightly better, with a rating of just over 2/5

The most helpful review states that Discount Tires is great at what it does – selling cheap tires. And should not be judged on services that it does not perform, such as wheel alignment, detail your vehicle, or check and change your oil.

For what it’s worth, I think you need to take these scores with a pinch of salt.

Both Discount and Costco seem to offer a very similar, no frills service in order to maintain the cheap prices of their tires and service.

Installation

Since Costco limits itself on the tires it will install for customers, you’re sure to get better installation service through Discount Tire.

What’s more, Discount Tire sometimes offers bundled deals where installation and balancing are included in the total sale price.

If you want a comprehensive installation service, Discount Tire is the better investment.