Truck Rental Home Depot vs Uhaul (Which Is Better)

Home Depot has smaller trucks with no reservation required.

On the other hand, U-Haul is available nationwide, and they have a ton of add-on services at competitive rates.

So which is better?

If you are looking for a mix of quality and convenience, then U-Haul is the ideal truck rental service for you. If you are searching for the best truck rental for hourly, last-minute moves, and small moving projects, then Home Depot is the perfect option for you! Your choice entirely depends on your preferences and needs.

Read on to find out the different truck sizes available, how to reserve a truck, and how much it will cost you.

truck rental home depot vs uhaul

1. Reserving A Truck

Reserving a truck with Home Depot is on a first-come, first-serve basis.

This means you can rent a truck for your move with no advance reservation.

You only need to visit the Home Depot website to check whether the truck you want is available, and then pick it up.

This makes Home Depot ideal for quick, local moves.

U-Haul is arguably one of the most popular truck rental companies.

For this reason, you have to reserve your preferred truck in advance to avoid last-minute disappointments.

The good news is that reserving a truck with U-Haul is extremely easy.

You can reserve a truck online via their user-friendly website, by phone, or in person. No deposit is required.

2. Cost

Home Depot offers one of the most affordable truck rental rates.

The company charges by the hour, with the base rate starting at $19 for the first 75 minutes and $5 for each additional 15 minutes after that.

However, the base rate can go as high as $29, depending on the type of truck you want to hire.

You also have to deposit between $50 and $100 when picking up the truck.

The deposit is nonetheless refundable as long as you bring back the truck in good condition.

Pricing FactorPickup TruckCargo VanBox Truck
Base Rate (first 75 minutes)$19$19$29
Extra Cost$5 every 15 minutes$5 every 15 minutes$5 every 15 minutes
Refundable Deposit$50$50$100

U-Haul has highly competitive rates as well.

However, instead of charging by the hour like Home Depot, U-Haul charges per mile.

They have a flat rate that ranges from $19.95 to $39.95, depending on the truck you want to rent.

However, these rates only apply to local moves, and you have to stay under an allotted number of miles.

Besides, U-Haul charges additional fees like damage protection, environmental fee, and fuel costs.

One more point – you must return the truck with the same amount of gas as when you picked it up!

Pricing Factor10 ft.15 ft.17 ft.20 ft.26 ft.
DistanceAllotted milesAllotted milesAllotted milesAllotted milesAllotted miles
Base Rate$19.95$29.95$29.95$39.95$39.95
Additional Mileage Rate$0.99 per mile$0.99 per mile$0.99 per mile$0.99 per mile$0.99 per mile
EZ-Load RampNoYesYesYesYes

You might also like: How To Afford A New Truck (Explained)

3. Truck Sizes

If you want to move all your stuff in one trip and save more money on truck rental costs, then you have to choose the right size moving truck.

Both Home Depot and U-Haul offer a variety of truck sizes to fit your needs.

Here is a list of truck sizes available from both truck rental companies.

Home Depot Truck Sizes

Truck Size12 ft.16 ft.22 ft.26 ft.Box Truck
Load Limit3,100 lbs.4,300 lbs.10,000 lbs.10,000 lbs.Varies from 3,850 lbs.
Capacity1-2 bedrooms2-3 bedrooms3-5 bedrooms5-7 bedrooms1-2 bedrooms
Auto TowingNoYesYesYesYes

U-Haul Truck Sizes

Truck Size8ft. Pickup10 ft.15 ft.17 ft.20 ft.26 ft.
Load Limit1,897 lbs.2,850 lbs.6,385 lbs.6,160 lbs.5,700 lbs.9,010 lbs.
CapacitySmall jobsStudio or 1 bedroom1-2 bedroomsUp to 2 bedrooms2-3 bedrooms3-4 bedrooms
Auto TowingNoYesYesYesYesYes

Knowing the right size truck for your move can sometimes be a huge challenge.

Here are a few questions you need to ask yourself to find the right truck for your needs:

  • How many bedrooms do I have in my current and next home?
  • How far will I be moving?
  • How many boxes am I moving?
  • Do I need to tow a car or add a trailer?
  • Do I have any bulky items that can’t fit in a box?
  • What’s my budget?

You might also like: Why Are Truck Campers So Expensive? (3 Reasons)

4. Number of Locations

Home Depot has over 2,200 locations around the country.

The numerous locations make it relatively easy to find a store near you.

However, once you rent a truck from a particular location, you must return it to the same location after your move.

This might sound inconvenient, especially if you are moving far away to another city or state. That’s why many people recommend Home Depot for local moves only.

U-Haul is one of the best truck rental companies in terms of locations.

The company has over 20,000 locations across the country.

What is even more amazing is that you can drop off the truck at a different location other than the one you picked it from as long as you call the main office in advance.

Another highlight about U-Haul is that you can install a hitch to your rented truck in any of the 20,000+ locations.

Besides, each location has its own set of trucks to fit your every need.

5. Truck Availability

Rental truck availability at Home Depot can be a little complicated since customers cannot make reservations in advance.

You can check if there are available trucks on the Home Depot website only to find them gone by the time you arrive at the nearest station.

Truck rental service at Home Depot is on a first-come, first-served basis.

To avoid any disappointments, it is advisable that you hire a truck during weekdays since the weekends tend to bring out a lot more people.

Truck availability with U-Haul has never been in question.

You can confirm the availability of your preferred truck via phone or through their website and then make a reservation.

With over 20,000 locations around the country, you can always rest assured you will find the ideal rental truck at a U-Haul station.

6. Locations

The headquarters of U-Haul is in Phoenix, Arizona, and they have thousands of locations across the nation.

This means finding a rental truck near you will not be a problem at all.

Similarly, Home Depot has around 2,200 locations around the country and they are headquartered in Atlanta, Georgia.

7. Drop Off

At Home Depot, each location has a certain number of trucks ready for renting.

For this reason, customers have to return the truck back to the same location it was hired from.

You are also required to return the truck with a full tank and in clean condition.

Failure of which, Home Depot may deduct part of your deposit to cater for the gas and cleaning costs.

The one main advantage that U-Haul has over Home Depot is that you can drop off your rented truck at any of their 20,000+ locations around the country.

However, you must first inform the head office (where you rented the truck from) in advance.

If you return your truck late, you should expect to pay a fine. U-Haul charges $40 per day (every 24 hours) for trucks returned late.

You might also like: CarMax (11 Common Questions Answered)

8. Customer Reviews

If you want to select the best truck rental service, you must go through customer reviews and feedback.

These valuable reviews will give you an idea of what to expect, especially if it is your first time renting a truck.

Here are a few customer reviews from both companies.

U-Haul Customer Reviews and Feedback

Most of the customer reviews about U-Haul were positive.

One customer by the name Ryan G was very happy with the services offered at his location.

His truck was clean and sanitized before he could rent it.

Another customer by the name Andrew W did not have a splendid experience.

He explains that an employee at U-Haul was highly unprofessional when he returned his rented truck late.

Home Depot Customer Reviews and Feedback

Home Depot has a few negative reviews from customers as far as truck rentals are concerned.

One customer called Matthew Bouchane was angry that he tried to reserve a truck via phone but he was unable to do so.

He had to stand in line for close to 20 minutes to reserve a truck.

Another customer named Hyun Cho-Steinberg had to contend with staff who were not willing to offer any help.

They were busy texting instead of attending to customers.

On a positive note, a customer named J S Jara was very happy with the help offered by the Home Depot staff.

Final Thoughts

As you would have noticed by now, Home Depot is great for quick local moves while U-Haul is ideal for long, inter-city, or inter-state relocations.

If you want to make a move, make sure you select the right truck rental service to save time and money.


Leave a Comment